I: Anniyan 2.0
Ann'I'yan
'Anniyan'
and 'I' had tremendous input and dedication from actor Vikram. Totally undeniable. In my opinion, I
would put my money on Vikram's performance in 'Anniyan.' The last time I
watched the movie, I was in school. I downloaded the movie and I found how graceful
and raging performance Vikram has given, especially Anniyan's voice (as much as
I loved Bale Batman's), and dialogue delivery. The dialogues were top notch.
Director Bala and Shankar are the only ones who were able to bring out the
talent Vikram had in him.
Now lets see the similarities, minor differences and
references 'I' has with 'Anniyan.'
The Name:
Vikram's name
in 'Anniyan' is Ramanujam aka Ambi.
It means 'The Younger Brother of Lord Rama.' Lord Ram is Vishnu's avatar.
Ramanujam is a Vaishnavite.
Vikram's name in 'I' is Lingesan. It means Hindu god Shiva. Brahmins who worship Shiva as the sole supreme are called Shaivite. Though Lingesan is not a Brahmin in the movie, his name is the other form of worship among Brahmins.
Vikram's name in 'I' is Lingesan. It means Hindu god Shiva. Brahmins who worship Shiva as the sole supreme are called Shaivite. Though Lingesan is not a Brahmin in the movie, his name is the other form of worship among Brahmins.
The Roles:
Both movies have the lead character
playing three roles.
Vikram portrays three characters, one with sinless
character, one as a model and the other who wants to punish.
We can ignore this look, as it has nothing to with
the story. Just part of the resolution.
Timeless Love:
Ambi loves Nandhini for several years. He collects
whatever is associated with her. The dried up flowers, greeting cards, photos,
hairpin, clips, rubber bands and so on. He has gifts too.
Lingesan also does the same. A box full of Diya's
endorsed products. But he is not in love with her. He is infatuated with her.
Kiss of Kamal:
Lingesan asks Diya to kiss him but not like how
Actor Kamal kisses on lips. Just on the cheek.
The Refusal:
Nandhini gets brutal. She rejects Ambi's proposal
point blank and he gets hurt badly. She leaves after breaking his heart.
Lingesan finds out Diya manipulated him and was not
truly in love with him. Gets his heart broken and walks away.
The Suicide Trial:
Ambi jumps into the river to kill himself, but he
doesn't die. He realizes committing suicide is against the law. Doesn't die.
Lingesan (hunchback) here tries to commit suicide
after Diya doesn't recognize him at the temple and thinks him to be a beggar.
He doesn't die and gets saved.
The Kidnap:
Lingesan (model) gets kidnapped in a strikingly
similar way but by goons in SUVs.
The Cover up:
Lingesan (model) gets only his face covered.
The Questioning:
Nandhini figures out Anniyan is Ambi. She gets
totally confused and questions the relationship about him and Remo.
Diya finds Lingesan's (model) mobile in hunchback's
pocket and questions how he got the mobile and his relationship with Lingesan.
The Revelation:
Doctor Vasudev tells Lingesan that he is suffering
from osteoporosis, a disease caused by genetic disorder.
The Psychiatrist tells Nandhini that Ambi is
suffering from multiple personality disorder.
This is another similar action I found. The good
Doctor from 'I' and the psychiatrist
from 'Anniyan' are holding the books in the same way.
The Stunts:
If you look at the below collage, you can see the similarities
in the number of stuntmen, their formations and weapons.
Colour Check:
Blue's means stability, trust, truth, loyalty,
cleanliness. 'Anniyan' has plenty of
blue tone painted over it. Sets with Anniyan's mentality.
We can see the antagonists have red on them or
around them when they are going to do to anything against good and during the
time any antagonist becomes a sufferer.
Lingesan about to get kidnapped and we see red
light.
VFX:
The VFX involving Lingesan's blood stream and
vessels are in red.
The Five:
The hunchback avenges these five people.
Bonus Reference:
???:
Now what I'm about to show may look silly to you.
This is funny but if you "consider"
all the similarities, differences and the reference 'I' had with 'Anniyan,'
it is hard to dismiss the above mentioned Lingesan's reference. Maybe a
coincidental premonition? We don't know.
'Anniyan'
moves
with an external conflict. It's about the people and country. That drives the
character forward. 'I' moves with an
internal conflict. Love.
My theory is, with above facts put together, Ramanujam
and Lingesan are the same person living in alternate worlds. Parallel Earth
theory.
Now let us come out of science. I don't know whether
the Director made these references deliberately. While reading this blog, you
would've got two ideas. Either 'I' is
a remodelled 'Anniyan' film or the
Director is a master of execution. This is an open ended blog. Decision is yours.
You have listed the external similarities which is good. I believe the internal character psyche, their similarity and differences needs to be analyzed too.
ReplyDelete1) In Anniyan 'Ambi' feels he is not good enough, so becomes Remo and Anniyan. In 'I', Lingesan feels he is not good enough for Amy. Hence becomes a model and... no he doesn't become the hunchback. He is made to become a hunchback by the evil doctor. So the transformation triggers in Anniyan were all internal, while that of I were partly internal and partly external.
2) Another difference is that in Anniyan, all 3 co-exists which made the story even complex and interesting. In 'I' it's linear - Lingesan is a body builder, then the model and then the hunchback. Linearness brought a bit of drab to the whole story in I. Whereas in 'Anniyan' you were busy figuring out how he managed all this as one person and hence you were engaged with the story.
3) Both these films are about when the 'identity' feels not enough - 'I' am not enough - and makes up for it by putting on a strong suit. The strong suit in 'Anniyan' was an act of being romantic (Remo) and being horrifying (Anniyan). Whereas the identity imposed on Lingesan is that of being suave (model) and being ugly (Hunchback)